Good Tanning creames?

i have like pale skin and i dont wanna go tanning and destroy my skin and i never attempt cause my friends mom, my mom, my aunt have skin cancer so im really carefull. I use Jergens Natural Glow in fair to medium and ive been putting it on for 4 days and my arms are fine but my legs look orange did i put to much on or am i not cleaning my skin well enough when i take a shower (which i take everyday) any tips or any good tanning lotions you recommend :) thanks!!